Current members of the ASFC include:
- Abraham Baldwin Agricultural College
- Alabama A&M University
- University of Arkansas at Monticello
- Auburn University
- Clemson University
- University of Florida
- University of Georgia
- Louisiana State University
- Louisiana Tech University
- Mississippi State University
- North Carolina State University
- Stephen F. Austin State University
- University of Tennessee
- Virginia Tech
The 1958 charter members of the ASFC were:
- Louisiana State University
- University of Florida
- Stephen F. Austin State University
- Mississippi State University
- University of Arkansas at Monticello
- University of the South
- Auburn University
- Oklahoma State University
- University of Georgia
- North Carolina State University
- Clemson University
Since its establishment in 1958, the following institutions have joined:
- Virginia Tech (1963)
- University of Tennessee (1967)
- Louisiana Tech University (1979)
- Alabama A&M University (2004)
- Abraham Baldwin Agricultural College (2013)
A number of institutions joined and left the organization over the years:
- University of the South (1958 - 1969)
- Texas A&M (1975 - 2011)
- West Virginia University (1981 only)
- Louisiana State University (1958 - 2004, 2009 - present)
- University of Kentucky (1975 - 1985, 2006 - 2016)
- Oklahoma State University (1958 - 2009)